
Best AI for Creative Writing: Test for Constraint, Not Pretty Sentences
The interesting question is not whether the prose is pleasant. It is whether the prose obeys: a point of view, a tense, a rule, a fact, an ending.
随笔
深入讨论产品内容、发布系统,以及那些不会写进更新日志的工程细节。
12 篇文章

The interesting question is not whether the prose is pleasant. It is whether the prose obeys: a point of view, a tense, a rule, a fact, an ending.

The question is not which one writes better sentences. It is which parts of the job you are actually buying, and which parts stay with you either way.

A generator can produce a competent draft in an afternoon. It cannot produce your cases, your numbers, your taste, or the decision about what the book is willing to say.

Novels fail in the middle for the same reason AI novels do: nothing is keeping the promises made in the first act. The fix is not a better model.

A chat window keeps a conversation. A book needs a plan, a set of facts it cannot contradict, a record of what has been covered, and a file at the end. That is a different object.

Demo prose tells you almost nothing. What separates the tools is whether the book survives contact with chapter ten, and whether you can see the bill coming.

The model is the least interesting decision in the process. What decides whether the book is readable is what you hand it before it writes, and what you check afterwards.

The tell is rarely a single word. It is the shape of the paragraph, the symmetry of the list, and the sentence that explains a noun you already understood.